Top 5 Best Broadway Shows in NYC [2024 Reviews]

New York City offers all kinds of entertainment you can wish for. Vibrant nightlife, a variety of cafes and restaurants, sport competitions, and cultural events – you will never get bored in the Big Apple.

The number of theaters and concert halls is exquisite. All you need to do is choose an event to your liking and book in advance, especially during the high tourist season, as tickets usually sell out very quickly.

Broadway is the street known all around the world, mainly for its theaters and numerous musicals, which have become legendary. We highly recommend you to use a chance and catch one of the best plays in NYC, once you are in New York. And here is the list of Broadway’s best we made for you.

Best Shows in New York City

The Lion King On BroadwayChicago on BroadwayMJ The Musical on Broadway
editors choice
Location:Minskoff Theater, 200 W 45th St, New York, NYAmbassador Theatre, 219 W 49th Street, New York City, NYNeil Simon Theatre, 250 W 52nd St., New York City, NY
Start:7:00 PM7:00 PM1:00 PM
Duration:2.5 hours2.5 hours2.5 hours
Includes:Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling chargesShow ticket, all taxes, fees and handling chargesShow ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

Show Information & Booking

Show Information & Booking

Show Information & Booking

Quick Answer: The 7 Best Broadway Shows in New York City

  1. The Lion King On Broadway
  2. Chicago on Broadway
  3. MJ The Musical on Broadway
  4. Wicked on Broadway
  5. Disney’s Aladdin on Broadway
  6. Moulin Rouge on Broadway
  7. Back to the Future the Musical on Broadway

Broadway Shows in New York City Reviews

1. The Lion King On Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Minskoff Theater, 200 W 45th St, New York, NY
  • Show Time: 7:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.5 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

The Lion King is absolutely my favorite Broadway show, and it’s one that’s been running for over 25 years! This makes it one of the longest-running shows in all of Broadway history, so it’s no surprise that it’s not only my favorite, but that of countless others!

Thanks to its balance of amazing storytelling, one-of-a-kind music, and stunning visuals, it’s become known as a beloved classic that I feel everyone should see at least once.

The innovative stage design is one of the most impressive I’ve seen, bringing the African savanna and all its brilliant inhabitants to life in an unexpected way!

Featuring iconic music from Elton John and Hans Zimmer, along with traditional African rhythms, it’s exciting as well as emotionally-provoking (they’ll likely be stuck in your head for days, but in a good way!).

Aside from the iconic “Hakuna Matata”, “Circle of Life”, and “Can You Feel the Love Tonight”, there were plenty of other compositions I hadn’t remembered, that were incredible!

Of course, with such amazing music, costumes, and storytelling, you have to have the choreography to live up to the rest of it. African dance styles are famous for being dynamic and energetic, which is exactly what you get here – a multi-sensory experience that will have you captivated from beginning to end.

Not to mention, it’s a sure winner for adults who’d like to go on a Broadway date night, just as well as entire families. With showings of both matinee and evening shows, it makes it much easier to fit into a busy New York schedule!

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


2. Chicago on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Ambassador Theatre, 219 W 49th Street, New York City, NY
  • Show Time: 7:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.5 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

Next up is another Broadway classic which is also one of the longest-running in the city’s history! It first premiered all the way back in 1975, and while that one is a bit different, the revival we see now has been running since 1996!

This is one of those shows I feel like perfectly encapsulates the spirit of Broadway, with its sharp wit, lots of drama, a bit of sass, and plenty of incredible music and choreography.

With multiple Tony Awards and a popular film adaptation, Chicago is iconic in the United States! I was originally recommended this one from an experienced theatergoer, but I know that it’s super popular with newbies, as well.

From my own experience, it’s no surprise, considering the fantastic style, great stories, and high-quality entertainment it provides all the way through.

In contrast to the flamboyant Lion King set design, Chicago’s is more minimalist, with cabaret-style staging, which lends to the Prohibition-era Chicago vibe. However, the fierce and cunning characters ensure there’s no lack of entertainment, pulling audiences into their intense storylines.

With themes of crime, corruption, more “advanced” humor, and plenty of adult scenarios, I wouldn’t necessarily say that this show is suitable for families with younger kids. However, I can definitely see plenty of older teens enjoying it!

With a wide range of different seating areas (I recommend one of the first 5 rows), you can enjoy a prime view and see Alyssa Milano make her Broadway debut, who you may already know from various popular tv series and movies!

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


3. MJ The Musical on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Neil Simon Theatre, 250 W 52nd St., New York City, NY
  • Show Time: 1:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.5 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

Celebrating the “King of Pop” is no easy feat, considering Jackson’s completely revolutionary trajectory. From iconic music videos and dance moves, to his distinct voice and unmatchable melodies, to his insane live performances – no one has been able to replicate the magic he evoked.

However, MJ The Musical manages to seamlessly capture the essence of his groundbreaking performances and reveals the ups-and-downs of his legendary career.

I’ll admit that while I enjoyed quite a few of his hit songs, I wouldn’t have considered myself a big fan of Michael Jackson before I saw the show. In fact, I imagined I’d probably be checking my watch throughout, to see when it was going to end

I was very pleasantly surprised from the very moment the show started, with an electrifying beginning that instantly caught my attention and didn’t let go. While I’d say it’s a family-friendly show, there are various aspects that delve into certain

themes that are probably better suited to teens and adults. I feel that artistic minds, in general, would really find inspiration thanks to the insight into his creative process and the struggles he went through.

Even though I was never able to see him in real life, this is as close as I’ll ever come, and it was quite the experience! There are no bad seats for this show, in my opinion. It’s a must-do when in NYC, and it’s one that will surely leave you inspired and one you need to see even if you like MJ just a tiny bit.

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


4. Wicked on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Gershwin Theatre, 242 W 51st St, New York City, NY
  • Show Time: 2:00 PM & 8:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.75 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

This is yet another that I was a bit hesitant to see, as I’d never been a big fan of “The Wizard of Oz” and knew it was kind of a twist on that classic. However, I was soon captivated by Wicked just as well as everyone else was, so I’ve learned not to judge a book by its cover!

Focusing more on the backstory of Elphaba, the Wicked Witch of the West, and her friendship with Glinda, the Good Witch, it’s perfect for entire families. If you’re looking for a fun few hours out with the fam, this show is perfect and super convenient to catch at the Gershwin Theater.

You have your choice from various matinee and evening showtimes as well, working into your schedule seamlessly. f you want to catch a Broadway show with a great message and isn’t at all scary, this is it.

Wicked focuses on themes like friendship, being perceived within society, identity, and so much more. It’s great if you have a child who is struggling with their own identity or how their peers see them, and will surely give them some peace of mind.

The score by Stephen Schwartz was also quite impressive, tying into said themes of self-acceptance and empowerment. The costumes and sets were all elaborate and there was never a moment of boredom, essentially bringing the Land of Oz to life in front of our eyes.

Make sure you bring some tissues, because this powerful performance will likely leave you in happy tears a few times!

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


5. Disney’s Aladdin on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: New Amsterdam Theatre, 214 W 42nd St, New York, NY
  • Show Time: 7:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.5 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

It’s no easy feat bringing Disney classics to life, and even though The Lion King was pulled off quite well, it’s the exception rather than the rule. However, Disney’s Aladdin on Broadway is right alongside it as one of the best adaptations a beloved animated film.

The production features elaborate sets and thoughtful costumes that almost make you feel like you’re in the magical city of Agrabah.

This rendition of the 1992 film brings all the original cast of characters to the stage that you know and love, making it ideal for adults and children, alike. With plenty of rich, vibrant colors and a storyline revolving around royalty, expect opulence and wild clothing!

Something I wasn’t expecting was the high level of energy and interesting tricks involved (like fireworks!) – something that absolutely kept the younger kids’ attention!

The choreography is dynamic and fun, and showcases the costumes perfectly. You’ll recognize plenty of songs from the animated film, as well as some new ones by Alan Menken that add a bit of freshness to the story.

With a nice balance of humor, hardships, magic, and romance, there are many different layers to appeal to any theatregoer. Right in the heart of Broadway you’ll find New Amsterdam theater, so it’s very easy to find and get inside.

It’s a beautiful theater, and a great “intro” to Broadway, so if you’re hesitant, definitely check this one out! If you want a show that focuses on being true to oneself, Aladdin sure does leave a lasting impression.

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


6. Moulin Rouge on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Al Hirschfeld Theatre, 302 W 45th St, New York City, NY
  • Show Time: 7:00 PM
  • Duration: 2.75 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

If you’re looking for a Broadway show that is practically guaranteed to impress, look no further than Moulin Rouge! That’s right – you don’t have to go all the way to Paris to experience the magic of this astonishing show!

The fantastic fusion of theatricality and modern pop music reimagines the classic 2001 film into a high-quality production with opulence and precision in every aspect.

Going into the show was very pleasant, with polite staff welcoming us into the Al Hirchfield theatre, with quick security. Our seats were amazing, and the theater was beautiful, with all its fantastic décor and lighting.

The scenography was one of the most impressive out of all the Broadway shows I’d been to, with lavish sets, bold costumes, and on-point choreography that worked together to transport us to the bohemian late-19th-century Paris.

The elaborate design will immerse you in the famous cabaret, which is exciting, seductive, and evokes a sense of wonder that will have you pondering what’s next!

Of course, it’s famous for its musical aspect, which is a dynamic mix of beloved pop hits from various eras, creatively woven into the storyline (along with some new songs to freshen things up!). The performances were amazing, with powerful vocals, evocative acting, and impressively fast costume changes!

Exploring themes of passion, sacrifice, and following your dreams, it’s more geared towards adult audiences, though there’s nothing overtly “adult”.

Overall, I’d say it’s a fantastic option for anyone looking for a show offering emotional depth, visually-impressive details, and a modern soundtrack that most will recognize.

Tour Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


7. Back to the Future the Musical on Broadway

Show Highlights at a Glance:

  • Location: Winter Garden Theatre, 1634 Broadway, New York City, NY
  • Show Time: 7:30 PM
  • Duration: 2.75 hours
  • Includes: Show ticket, all taxes, fees and handling charges

The Back to the Future the Musical on Broadway has won all kinds of awards, from the Olivier Award for “Best New Musical”, 4 “WhatsOnStage” awards, and has quickly become one of the crowd favorites!

Whether you’ve seen the original movie or would like to, this show is a fantastic alternative – they even sound like the film actors! This is a fun-filled, lighthearted show perfect for all ages, with tons of cool effects!

Bringing an 80s vibe to the modern-day stage, this show captures the movie through a fresh lens with the same magic and humor the original fans loved. However, it did introduce plenty of new aspects and inventive uses of technology that I found cool.

I’d say this show had some of the most impressive visual effects and smart set transformations I’ve seen – particularly the iconic DeLorean time machine!

The score features plenty of the original songs and classics from the film, keeping energy high throughout the show. The cast’s performances were amazing, honoring the characters from the film while injecting a fresh charisma and uniqueness that spices things up.

Their chemistry with each other was contagious, and it was clear that they were close, which only added to the on-point performances.

I’d say with this one there are also no “bad” seats, but for the most immersive experience possible, definitely try to get some up close! Be prepared for lots of laughs and an overall heartwarming, nostalgia-invoking time on Broadway no matter if you’re a newbie, or your age!

Show Information & Booking

100% refund for cancellations within 24 hours of tour experience


Your Guide to Visiting New York City

Best Broadway Shows - Guide Image

Airports & Entry

The city of New York has three main airports: John F Kennedy International Airport, La Guardia Airport, and Newark Liberty International Airport.

AirTrain is the most convenient way to get from JFK Airport to the city. It connects the subway with the airport and you can get to Manhattan in an hour and for a cost of just $2.75. Other way to get to the center is to take an express bus to Grand Central Terminal or Port Authority, which will take you 1,5 hour and cost you $18.

The approximate taxi fare is $52, but tolls, tips, and rush hour surcharges are not included. Taxis can be found at the taxi dispatch booths. Or you can use services such as Uber.

Although La Guardia is situated closest to Manhattan, it is considered the least accessible by public transport airport of New York City. To get to the center, you need to take an express bus #Q70, which will bring you to the 74th Street – Broadway metro station and will cost you $15.

The flat taxi cost varies between $34 and $53, excluding tips and tolls. Uber service is also an option.

To get to New York City center from Newark Liberty International Airport, take an AirTrain to Newark Airport train station. There you can change to any train, which goes to New York Penn station, and it will cost you $13.

Taxi fares vary from $60 to $80, and do not include tips or tolls. You can take a taxi, use Uber, or choose a similar service.

Planning Tips

If you are planning to visit a musical, you won’t be needing an evening gown. Your clothes can be casual (dark jeans and a shirt will do), but neat and clean. A cocktail dress for a woman will be appropriate. But you won’t need your diamonds or a bow tie.

You should also consider your other plans for New York City, before making a packing list. Are you planning to walk a lot? Bring comfortable shoes or snickers. Going for a picnic in the Central Park? Planning to dine in a luxury establishment? All your plans will require different clothing.

And don’t forget to book all your tickets in advance. Tickets for such events as Broadway musicals sell out weeks before the date. Keep that in mind, when planning your trip itinerary.

Restaurants & Eating Out

The one thing you can be sure about, when traveling to New York City, is that you won’t get hungry. Restaurants, cafes, bistros, bars, and street vendors are multiple and can fit any taste or budget. Small family cafes and huge world-known restaurant chains, fast food bistros and luxury top-end restaurants, street food of all kinds – all of these can be found in New York.

The variety of different cuisines is exquisite: French, Greek, Italian, Mexican, Middle Easter, Chinese, Japanese, Thai, Indian, Vietnamese – this is just a short list of what you can taste in the Big Apple.

If you are on a low budget and want to cook for yourself, visit the markets: Chelsea and Fulton 55, where you can find all kinds of fresh ingredients for your meals, as well as many street food vendors and budget cafes. To get the best taste of NYC, we would recommend taking a guided NYC food tour.

There is also a list of must-try foods and drinks of New York. They don’t necessarily originate from the city, but they have definitely gained their particular features here and must be appreciated. So, if you want to feel like a real New Yorker, don’t avoid:

  • Hot dog
  • Bagels
  • Cheesecake New York
  • Pizza
  • Sandwich
  • Egg Cream
  • Long Island Ice Tea

Nightlife & Entertainment

New York City is, probably, the world’s winner for the number of night establishments opening every week, as well as for ones that close. Every district of the city has a variety of night clubs and bars for every taste and wallet size.

If you stay in Manhattan, you should visit Greenwich Village, which is filled with night entertainment facilities, popular with both locals and tourists. Since the NYU students are the biggest part of the local public here, the prices are quite reasonable. If you are up for something more elegant, head to Chelsea or Lower East Side.

And, of course, even if you stay in Queens, Staten Island, or Brooklyn, you won’t feel the lack of night entertainment either. New York is the city, which never sleeps.

Jazz is another thing that you can always find in the Big Apple. It is called the world capital of jazz for a reason. In the past, the city has revealed hundreds of jazz musicians and presented them to the world. Nowadays, there are still numerous establishments, where you can enjoy a drink with your friends or date, while listening to some good jazz.

The Blue Note, situated in Greenwich Village, is, probably, the most well-known jazz club, as well as the Village Vanguard, located in the same district. However, these are the places for people with high travel budget. If you are looking for something simpler and cheaper, head to Fat Cat or Smalls, standing just a block away from each other, also in Greenwich Village.

If you are into passionate Afro-Caribbean music and love Latina dancing, New York City is a great place for you too! Salsa, although originates from Cuba, has rooted deeply in the cultural life of New York. The most popular places are Copacabana near the Times Square, which opened its doors for the first time in the 1940’s, Iguana in West Midtown, and El Morocco in Spanish Harlem.

If you consider yourself more of a classical music lover, choose one of the multiple opera, ballet, or musical performances, which the city offers. Head to Carnegie Hall, Radio City Music Hall, or one of the Broadway theaters, in order to enjoy a nice classical evening. Check out the list of the best musicals in New York, which we prepared for you, and don’t forget to book in advance!

And, of course, you can’t feel real New York without attending one of the sport matches. Most New Yorkers are passionate sport fans and have their favorite baseball, hockey, or basketball team. Join them for a night of sport fun, and don’t forget to pick up souvenirs with the name of the team you like!

Getting Around

Getting around the city of New York is not difficult, as it has an extremely extended system of public transportation. Subway, buses, commuter rail, as well as ferries, operate on a regular basis.

The simplest way to get from one point to another inside the city limits is by subway. You might be scared by the horror stories about New York subway criminal situation, but it’s almost completely in the past nowadays. Anyway, you should still beware and not attract criminals.

The rules of safety are quite clear: don’t show your valuables in public, don’t walk alone at night, try to take crowded trains and use crowded stations. If you keep that in mind, most likely, you’ll be safe.

However, if you don’t feel secure enough, it’s better to take a taxi. World-famous yellow cabs have become a real symbol of New York, along with the Empire State Building, Central Park, and the Statue of Liberty. This is, probably, the second most popular way of transportation among New Yorkers, after subway.

Cabs are multiple, comfortable and reasonably-priced. To get one, all you need to do is raise your arm standing at the edge of the pavement. Keep in mind, though, it might be hard to catch a taxi during the rush hours. And, of course, remember about traffic jams. It might be better to take a subway if you are in a hurry!

Ferries connect the heart of New York with its islands. Staten Island Ferry starts at the Battery Park in the south of Manhattan and goes to Staten Island. It’s not only a great way of transportation, but also an opportunity to see New York Harbor and the Statue of Liberty on the way. The big bonus is that it’s free.

New York Waterway Company operates ferries between the city and New Jersey Hudson River Waterfront, stopping also in Brooklyn and Queens. These ferries are not free, so keep that in mind.

New York Water Taxi are ferries painted yellow, like famous New York cabs. They connect points within Manhattan, as well as some points in Brooklyn and New Jersey.

Accommodations

The Big Apple is, probably, one of the most expensive cities to live in. If you decide to visit New York, be ready to pay, at least, $100 for a double room in a hotel, and a minimum of $50 for a bed in a hostel dormitory. However, that is if you want to stay in Manhattan. But there are other districts in New York City, of course. If you choose Queens, Brooklyn, Long Island, or New Jersey, you can find much cheaper accommodations of the same quality as in Manhattan.

When traveling during the low tourist season – in January, February, or August, you can also save your traveler’s budget, as hotels usually reduce prices during this time of year. As for the days of week, Sunday is usually the cheapest day to rent a room in New York City.

When booking, keep in mind that fares are often mentioned without taxes. If you add all the taxes for New York State and New York City, you will end up with a 15%-higher price. Be ready to pay it on arrival.

Weather

New York City has continental climate, with hot summers, cold winters, cool autumns, and wet springs. In winter, the temperature can fall as low as -18oC, and during the summer, it can raise as high as to +38oC.Keep in mind, during the summer months, as well as in September, New York can experience heavy tropical storms, so bring a raincoat. Snowstorms occur often in winter, but the snow usually does not last longer than a couple of days.

Attractions

New York is the city, which you can explore for weeks: admiring the skyscrappers, having lovely picnics in the parks, taking pictures, listening to stories, and buying souvenirs. However, if you have limited time, here is a list of main attractions you should not miss.

Landmarks: the Statue of Liberty, Wall Street, Federal Hall, World Trade Center Site, Brooklyn Bridge, Empire State Building, Chrysler Building, Grand Central Terminal, New York Public Library, Rockefeller Center, Radio Music Hall, and Times Square.

Museums: the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Guggenheim Museum, the Whitney Museum of American Art, the Frick Collection, the Museum of Modern Art, the Brooklyn Museum of Art, the PS1 Contemporary Art Center, the American Museum of Natural History, the New York Hall of Science, and the Transit Museum.

Parks: Central Park, Fort Tryon Park, Pelham Bay Park, Prospect Park, Flushing Meadow Park, the Greenbelt, and parts of the Gateway National Recreational Area.

If you see these places, you can honestly say that you have seen the most interesting spots in New York. However, if you want to get the most out of your time in New York City, we highly recommend taking a daily bus tour. Anyway, a trip to New York will become something you’ll remember for the rest of your life!

Show
Theatre
Value

The Lion King On Broadway is our top pick for the best NYC broadway show.

User Rating: Be the first one !

Shayanne DeCastro

Shayanne is a freelance writer, wine snob and marketer based in LA, California. Describing herself as a nomad, she has lived in many different cities including Boise, Idaho and Seattle, Washington as well as Guadalajara, Mexico. She is forever on the move. Being an extremely active person, she loves to snowboard, skateboard, and ski. She enjoys sharing her love for active sports with others through her “how to” sports guides as well as food and wine reviews. Her love for wine and good food shines through every paragraph. While she travels, Shayanne loves to try new restaurants and wineries.  If there is a winery or good restaurant in your town, you will probably meet her one day.
Back to top button